Why civility in political discourse matters at College
Following the recent general election, it would be both inappropriate and impertinent of me to offer a personal commentary on the result. Political views are rightly a matter of individual conviction, and our role as educators is not to tell people what to think, but to equip them with the knowledge, judgement and character to think for themselves.
Earlier this year, I asked our College prefects a question: How many of them would consider a future career in politics? Of this group of outstanding young men, just one hand went up. I found that concerning.
Our prefects are chosen because they demonstrate leadership attributes, and they are, in my opinion, the very young men we should be encouraging to consider public service. It is my hope that as they graduate from College, they understand leadership, responsibility and the importance of serving something greater than themselves. Yet, when the nature and tone of political discourse risk overshadowing the importance of public service, we may inadvertently discourage talented young men from seeing politics as a worthwhile and honourable calling.
Democracy depends upon disagreement. Indeed, the freedom to challenge ideas, question decisions and hold those in authority to account is fundamental to a healthy society. But too often, disagreement gives way to hostility and the ability to listen respectfully to an opposing view is mistaken for weakness. I think we should be concerned about creating a political environment that discourages the very people we most need to participate.
At Christ’s College, our responsibility extends well beyond academic achievement. We seek to educate boys who have the confidence to form their own opinions, the intellectual courage to challenge the status quo and the humility to recognise that they may not always be right. We must teach our boys to debate ideas and to disagree without condescension. They should never be afraid to express a considered opinion, even when it is unpopular. Equally, they must understand that a difference of opinion is never an invitation to diminish the dignity of another person.
Our College virtues are not simply ideals to be discussed in Chapel or displayed around the school. They must find expression in how we engage with others, particularly those whose perspectives differ from our own.
Ultimately, politics is an expression of service. At its best, it is about people willing to devote their talents and energy to improving the lives of others. Whatever our political convictions, we should want capable, principled and compassionate people to see public office as a worthwhile and honourable calling.
I hope that, in years ahead, when I ask that same question, considerably more hands will go up. Not because we have encouraged students towards any particular political persuasion, but because we have helped them understand that their voices matter and that leadership is ultimately about service.
Read on